Here is our only pitching category with an innings limit, which I have arbitrarily put at 400 innings pitched.

Let’s take a look:

2006-2019
1 Frank Gailey New Market ’05-06 2.71
2 Chad Kuhl New Market ’12 2.75
3 Rob Delaney New Market ’03 2.89
4 Austin Gomber Luray ’12 2.95
5 Robby Scott Covington ’10 3.06
6 Ryan Yarbrough Luray ’12 3.25
7 Rowdy Hardy Staunton ’04 3.29
8 Stephen Kohlscheen Harrisonburg ’10 3.39
9 Kevin Herget Strasburg ’12 3.40
10 Chris Masters New Market ’07 3.52
11 Ryne Reynoso Waynesboro ’05 3.66
12 Brandon Dickson New Market ’06 3.74
13 Drew Granier Harrisonburg ’09-10 3.80
14 Sam Howard Staunton ’12 3.85
15 Elih Villanueva Luray ’07 3.88
16 Chris Huffman Staunton ’12-3 3.91

Robby Scott is the only pitcher to join this list- up there at fifth. Tyler Thornburg fell off the list, as his career ERA is now 4.09.

All-Time
1 Lee Gronkiewicz New Market ’98 2.42
2 Frank Gailey New Market ’05-06 2.71
3 Chad Kuhl New Market ’12 2.75
4 Rob Delaney New Market ’03 2.89
5 Saul Rivera New Market ’97 2.90
6 Austin Gomber Luray ’12 2.95
7 Mike Christopher Winchester ’84 3.03
8 Robby Scott Covignton ’10 3.06
9 Greg Hibbard Staunton 3.08
10 Jeff Johnson Winchester ’86 3.10
11 Jeff Tam Harrisonburg ’92 3.11
12 Colter Bean Winchester ’97 3.16
13 Bob Patterson Madison ’81 3.22
14 Ryan Yarbrough Luray ’12 3.25
15 Rowdy Hardy Staunton ’04 3.29
16 Jason Arnold Staunton 3.33
17 Daryl Irvine Harrisonburg 3.34
Justin Pope Staunton 3.34
19 Jeff Mutis Staunton 3.35
20 Elvys Quezada Winchester ’02 3.37

With Scott moving on, Stephen Kohlscheen fell off.

Gailey
Kuhl